Unpaid internships have been a topic of debate for many years, especially in California, where labor laws are known to be some of the strictest in the country. Many students and young professionals are eager to gain experience in their chosen fields, and internships often seem like a great way to do so. But what happens when those internships don’t come with a paycheck? Are unpaid internships legal in California? The answer isn’t always straightforward. To understand the legality of unpaid internships, it’s important to look at both federal and state labor laws. At, sickandfired.com lawyers , we are here to guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of your case.
Our Attorneys
Federal Labor Laws and Internships
The Fair Labor Standards Act, also known as the FLSA, is a federal law that sets standards for wages, overtime pay, and other labor-related issues. Under this law, workers are entitled to be paid at least the federal minimum wage for their work. However, there are exceptions for certain types of internships. The U.S. Department of Labor has created a set of guidelines, known as the “primary beneficiary test,” to help determine whether an internship can be unpaid.
The primary beneficiary test is a set of seven factors used to assess whether the intern or the employer benefits more from the internship. If the intern is the primary beneficiary, meaning they are gaining valuable training and experience, the internship may be unpaid. On the other hand, if the employer is the one gaining the most benefit from the intern’s work, the intern should be considered an employee and must be paid at least the minimum wage.
Some of the key factors in the primary beneficiary test include whether the internship is tied to the intern’s formal education program, whether it provides hands-on training similar to what would be provided in an educational setting, and whether the intern’s work complements, rather than displaces, the work of paid employees. If these factors suggest that the intern is not an employee, the internship may legally be unpaid.
California State Labor Laws and Internships
In addition to federal labor laws, California has its own labor laws that must be considered. California law is often more protective of workers’ rights than federal law, and this is also true when it comes to internships. The California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, or DLSE, has its own set of rules for determining whether an intern is an employee entitled to wages.
The DLSE follows a similar set of guidelines to the federal primary beneficiary test but is often stricter in its interpretation. For example, under California law, an internship must primarily benefit the intern and be an extension of the intern’s formal education. The internship must also be structured in a way that provides the intern with training and educational experience that is similar to what they would receive in a school setting. If the intern is performing work that would normally be done by a paid employee, they must be paid for their time.
California law also places a strong emphasis on the idea that internships should not be exploitative. This means that companies cannot use unpaid interns as free labor to complete tasks that are essential to their business. If an intern is expected to perform tasks that benefit the company more than they benefit the intern, the company may be violating California labor laws.
Danielle, Carie, and Perry are the best to work with! They showed so much compassion and care for my case. They kept me updated every step of the way and helped me understand the process of the case. I am very happy with my outcome of my case. Thank you again sickandfired.com lawyers.” - Janel Daniels This was such a new experience for me and I’m glad I called on the right team to do what was needed. You guys made sure to calm my nerves and make this horrible process so easy. Thanks again for going above and beyond." - Thomas Dede Thank you to Perry Smith and his team. From the beginning Perry and his team were clear about their services and laying the groundwork for the process of what I may expect. When I had any questions an email or phone call was made and my questions were immediately answered. Perry handled the case in an efficient manner and their communication let me know that I was in good professional hands. Once again, thank you." - Anonymous
Educational Internships vs. Non-Educational Internships
Another important distinction in the legality of unpaid internships in California is whether the internship is connected to an educational program. Internships that are part of a formal education program, such as those required for college credit, are more likely to be legally unpaid. This is because the intern is considered to be receiving educational benefits rather than performing work for the company.
However, internships that are not connected to an educational program are often more difficult to justify as unpaid. If an internship is not part of a school program and does not offer significant educational benefits, the intern is more likely to be considered an employee under both federal and California law. In these cases, the intern must be paid for their time.
For example, if a company hires an unpaid intern to complete tasks like filing, answering phones, or managing social media accounts, this type of work is likely considered essential to the company’s operations. In such cases, the intern would be entitled to compensation, as they are performing the same tasks that a paid employee would typically do.
Internships and Non-Profit Organizations
One exception to the rules surrounding unpaid internships in California is for internships with non-profit organizations. Non-profits are often allowed to offer unpaid internships, as long as the intern is volunteering their time and not performing work that would otherwise be done by a paid employee. Interns at non-profit organizations are generally considered volunteers, which means they are not entitled to wages under California or federal law.
However, even in non-profit internships, there are still rules that must be followed. The intern must genuinely be volunteering their time and not working under the expectation of receiving a paid position in the future. Additionally, the intern cannot be performing tasks that are essential to the operation of the non-profit. If the intern is doing work that directly benefits the organization and is necessary for its operations, they may be entitled to wages.
How sickandfired.com lawyers can help after you've been wrongfully terminated.
What should I do if I believe I have been wrongfully terminated from my job?
Related Videos
Interns and Worker Protections
Even if an internship is legally unpaid, interns in California still have certain protections under the law. For example, unpaid interns are protected from discrimination and harassment in the workplace. Just like paid employees, unpaid interns have the right to a safe and respectful work environment. If an intern is being mistreated because of their race, gender, age, or any other protected characteristic, they may have the right to take legal action against their employer.
Unpaid interns are also protected under California’s workers’ compensation laws. This means that if an intern is injured while performing their internship duties, they may be entitled to workers’ compensation benefits, even if they are not being paid for their time. Employers are required to provide workers’ compensation coverage for all workers, including unpaid interns.
How to Know if an Internship Should Be Paid
Determining whether an internship should be paid can be complicated, especially with the various federal and state laws that apply. If you are unsure whether your internship should be paid, it may be helpful to consider a few key questions.
First, ask yourself whether the work you are doing is similar to the work of paid employees. If you are performing tasks that would normally be completed by a paid employee, you are likely entitled to wages. Next, consider whether the internship is tied to your formal education. If you are receiving school credit or other educational benefits, the internship may legally be unpaid. Finally, think about who is benefiting more from the internship: you or the company. If the company is gaining the most benefit from your work, you should probably be paid for your time.
It’s also important to remember that just because an internship is labeled as “unpaid” doesn’t mean it is legal. If your internship doesn’t meet the requirements of both federal and California labor laws, you may be entitled to back pay for the work you have done.
What to Do if Your Internship Is Illegal
If you believe your unpaid internship violates federal or California labor laws, you may have legal options. You could be entitled to compensation for the time you spent working, as well as other damages. It’s important to seek legal guidance if you think your rights as an intern have been violated. A lawyer with experience in employment law can help you determine whether your internship was legal and what steps you can take to recover any unpaid wages.
If you’re concerned about the legality of your unpaid internship, or if you believe your rights have been violated, it’s important to act. The legal process can be complex, and having a trusted legal team by your side can make all the difference. At sickandfired.com lawyers, we are dedicated to helping interns and workers understand their rights and get the compensation they deserve. If you need help with your case, reach out to us today. Let sickandfired.com lawyers guide you through this process and ensure that your rights are protected.